This checker decides two things in order: whether your space passes the gate both home office methods stand behind, and — if it does — which method is larger on your figures. The gate comes first on purpose: a space that fails it gets neither method, however large the numbers would have been. The itemised version of the same comparison lives in the Home Office Deduction Calculator at the end.
How this verdict works
The rules below are the whole logic of the checker — the verdict implements them exactly as stated, and each rule names its primary source.
- The gate: exclusive and regular use. A deduction for business use of a home requires the portion to be used exclusively and regularly for business. A space used for both business and personal purposes fails the exclusive-use test. (IRS, Simplified option for home office deduction, comparison of methods; Publication 587, Qualifying for a Deduction.)
- The gate: a qualifying business use. The space must be the principal place of business, or a place where you meet or deal with clients or customers in the normal course of business, or a separate structure used in connection with the business. (Publication 587, same section.) Storage of inventory and daycare use follow their own exceptions, which this checker does not apply — a space kept for those uses needs Publication 587 directly.
- The gate: not as an employee. Taxpayers can no longer claim a deduction for use of a home office as an employee, because miscellaneous itemized deductions for employee business expenses were eliminated for tax years beginning after 2017 — whichever method is used. (IRS, Simplified option page.)
- Simplified method. $5 per square foot of home used for business, counting at most 300 square feet — a maximum deduction of $1,500. No expense records are required for the amount, and allowable home-related itemized deductions are claimed in full on Schedule A. (Same IRS page; Revenue Procedure 2013-13.)
- Regular method (as estimated here). The business-use percentage — office area divided by total home area — applied to the home's actual expenses, with records maintained. An actual claim is figured on Form 8829; this checker's figure is the percentage-times-expenses estimate, before that form's own adjustments. (Same IRS page; Publication 587.)
- Depreciation differs, exactly. Under the simplified option there is no home depreciation deduction and no later recapture of depreciation for the years it is used. Under the regular method there is a depreciation deduction for the portion used for business, and recapture of depreciation on gain upon sale of the home. (Same IRS page, comparison of methods.)
- The choice is annual. Either method may be chosen for any taxable year, by using it on the timely filed original return for that year; once chosen for a year it cannot be changed for that same year. (Same IRS page, Selecting a method.)
Reading the verdict
A gate failure is stated plainly and kindly on purpose: it is the most useful answer this page can give, because it arrives before a return is filed on the wrong assumption. When the gate passes, the verdict shows both figures and names the larger one — with the standing caution that the regular figure is an estimate before Form 8829, so a small gap in the regular method's favour may not survive the form, while the simplified figure is exact as computed.
Estimates for planning only. This checker is not tax advice. Eligibility turns on all the facts of the space and the business; verify against Publication 587 or with a qualified tax professional before filing.